All Blogs/ Bathroom And Bidet Design

Bidet Showdown: Comparing Hand-held, Attachment, Seat-Mounted, and Smart Systems

3 November 2023 · JOHN PHUNG · 18 min read
    Bathroom and Bidet Design
woman in bathroom

Table of Contents

    Loading the Text to Speech Audio Player...

    Bidets are no longer a foreign concept, but with so many varieties out there, finding the right one for you can be a puzzle.

    We're here to simplify that puzzle by comparing four different types of bidets: hand-held bidets, toilet seat attachment bidets, toilet seat mounted bidets, and smart toilet bidet systems. Let's dive in!

    Hand-held Bidet: What Is It? 

    bumwash bidet spray

    A hand-held bidet, often referred to as a bidet spray or shower bidet, is a simple yet effective tool for enhancing personal cleanliness.

    Resembling a mini hand-held shower, the bidet spray is a flexible hose with a nozzle at the end. Its simple design and ease of use make it a popular choice for those looking to venture into the world of bidets without making major alterations to their existing toilet setup.

    Functionality:

    The hand-held bidet provides a direct stream of water to the area you aim at, usually with adjustable pressure, making it a straightforward cleaning solution after using the toilet.

    However, mastering the correct angling and positioning of the bidet spray may require a few tries, especially to avoid unwanted splashes around your bathroom. One of the advantages is that the flexibility of the hose allows for both front wash and rear wash, providing the bidet user different position preferences.

    Although effective, the need for proper control may pose a challenge for individuals with flexibility issues or those who find it hard to aim accurately.

    Installation:

    One of the primary advantages of a hand-held bidet is its easy to install. Typically, no special tools are required, and the installation doesn’t call for any modifications to the existing toilet system.

    Although considering adding an T-adapter or valve can prove to beneficial to the setup if one does not exist already. This feature is particularly beneficial for renters or those not wanting to alter their current toilet setup.

    While straightforward, ensuring a secure connection is crucial to prevent any leaks or drips.

    Cost Efficiency:

    When it comes to cost, hand-held bidets are often seen as the most budget-friendly option available. The initial investment is relatively low, and the savings on toilet paper over time make it a cost-effective choice for many households.

    The cost-benefit ratio becomes especially noticeable with regular use, as the savings on toilet paper quickly add up.

    Maintenance:

    Maintaining a hand-held bidet is fairly straightforward. Regular cleaning with non-abrasive cleaners will keep it hygienic and in good working condition. However, depending on the water quality, mineral build-up on the nozzle may occur over time, necessitating a thorough clean or possibly a replacement nozzle.

    User Friendliness:

    The simplicity of design and operation makes the hand-held bidet a user-friendly option. The learning curve mainly involves getting the hang of aiming the spray accurately to ensure effective cleaning without splashing water elsewhere.

    Affordability:

    As one of the most economical types of bidets, the hand-held bidet offers a great entry point for those curious about bidets but not ready to invest in more expensive integrated systems.

    Aesthetics:

    While functional, the aesthetic appeal of hand-held bidets may not match up to the sleek look of built-in bidet systems. However, they come in various designs and finishes, allowing for a level of aesthetic choice.

    Versatility:

    The mobile nature of hand-held bidets makes them a remarkably versatile tool in a variety of scenarios besides personal hygiene. Their flexible hose allows for easy reach and manoeuvrability, making them quite handy in different situations around the bathroom and beyond.

    For instance, they can be utilized for cleaning pets, especially after a muddy outdoor adventure, ensuring your furry friend is clean before hopping back onto the couch.

    The forceful spray can also be a boon for cleaning the toilet itself, particularly in removing stubborn toilet bowl stains that a brush alone might struggle with.

    Parents may find the hand-held bidet a convenient tool for cleaning babies during diaper changes, making the clean-up process a breeze while ensuring a thorough clean.

    The flexible reach of the hose also makes it an effective tool for rinsing cloth diapers, helping to remove solid waste before tossing them in the wash.

    With its ability to provide a direct stream of water wherever needed, the hand-held bidet proves to be a multifaceted tool that extends its utility well beyond personal cleaning after toilet use.

    Electricity Consumption:

    Hand-held bidets do not require electricity, making them an environmentally friendly and cost-effective choice.

    Toilet Seat Attachment Bidet: What’s the Deal?

    bidet seat attachment

    A Toilet Seat Bidet Attachment is an elegant addition to your existing toilet seat, morphing it into a bidet without the need for a separate unit.

    This slim device nestles under your toilet seat, offering controls to tweak water pressure and, in some models, water temperature to your preference. Here’s a more comprehensive delve into how it elevates modern hygiene in your restroom:

    Design

    The toilet seat bidet attachment is a fixed installation, unlike a hand-held bidet. It boasts a sleek, unobtrusive design that easily blends with contemporary bathroom aesthetics. Typically, it features control panels or dials on the side, letting you fine-tune the water pressure and, in some cases, the temperature.

    Functionality

    Utilising a gentle water spray, this kind of bidet purifies your posterior or genital area after toilet use, all controlled through a remote control for an enhanced restroom encounter.

    The nozzle emerges from beneath the seat, facilitating a hands-free cleansing journey. Many models come with adjustable nozzle positions to modulate the water pressure, and even the water temperatures can be tailored to your preference, ensuring every spray is just right.

    Although, they typically may lack a directional aim for the nozzle, which could lead to a less than satisfactory cleaning of the entire bum region. However, this fixed directional water aim could serve as a blessing for individuals with disabilities who might find the manual aiming required with hand-held bidets a bit challenging.

    The remote control feature further simplifies the operation, making it a breeze to regulate the water pressure and ensure each spray is gentle yet effective for an impeccable cleaning routine.

    Installation

    The installation process for a toilet seat bidet attachment is fairly straightforward, designed to fit under your existing toilet seat with the aid of a few basic tools. It connects to your toilet's water supply, assuring a constant source of clean water.

    It's pivotal that the system incorporates a backflow prevention mechanism to avert cross-contamination during low pressure situations. This might necessitate a plumber’s help, incurring additional setup costs.

    Usage

    Using this bidet is a breeze. Once set up, a turn of the dial or a button press activates the water spray. The control panel facilitates water pressure and, in some models, temperature adjustments to your liking.

    Maintenance

    While some models boast self-cleaning nozzles, this feature typically only uses water to rinse the nozzle, which may not be sufficient to remove all bacteria. Therefore, periodic manual cleaning is essential to ensure the bidet remains hygienic and fully functional.

    It's advisable to use appropriate cleaning solutions during manual cleaning to effectively eradicate bacteria and maintain the pristine condition of your bidet. Regular upkeep will ensure that your bidet continues to operate smoothly, providing a clean and refreshing experience after each use.

    Cost-Effectiveness

    Toilet seat bidet attachments are pricier than their hand-held counterparts. The return on investment often hinges on the usage frequency, reflected in the savings on toilet paper.

    However, they offer a middle ground between the affordability of hand-held bidets and the feature-rich but higher-priced toilet seat mounted or smart toilet bidet systems.

    Space-Saving

    The bidet attachment design negates the need for additional space, making it an excellent choice for compact bathrooms or for those who favour a less cluttered appearance.

    Toilet seat bidet attachments serve as a fantastic means to bolster bathroom hygiene without a major renovation. They strike a balance between functionality, installation ease, and cost-effectiveness, thereby garnering popularity among bidet enthusiasts.

    Toilet Seat Mounted Bidet: What’s Different?

    toilet seat bidet

    A Toilet Seat Mounted Bidet is a modern-day marvel that brings a touch of sophistication and enhanced hygiene to your bathroom regime.

    This type of bidet considered the best bidet seat for those looking for slightly more sophistication for their rear wash. Here's an in-depth exploration of its aesthetics, functionality, and installation process:

    Aesthetics and Appearance

    Bidet toilet seats are known for their sleek design which blends seamlessly with your existing toilet, adding a modern touch to your bathroom. Unlike the hand-held bidet sprayers or toilet seat attachment bidets, these come with a seat incorporated into the design, hence they replace your existing toilet seat.

    They are available in a variety of designs and finishes, ensuring that there's a perfect match for every bathroom decor. The bidet seats are usually streamlined and have a modern, high-tech look, sometimes accompanied by a side control panel or a remote control for operation.

    Functionality

    The core functionality of a toilet seat mounted bidet lies in its ability to provide a thorough clean with the simple press of a button. Most of these bidet seats come with a wand or rod, sometimes multiple, with a diameter slightly thicker than a pencil.

    This wand is normally housed inside the bidet seat when not in use, and often has a self-cleaning feature that operates after every use. The wand sprays water through built-in nozzles to provide a wash or cleanse.

    Many models on the market offer multiple nozzles each designed to spray water in a specific manner, optimizing the effectiveness for different wash settings​

    Usage

    Toilet seat mounted bidets offer a user-friendly experience, especially for those who prefer a hands-free cleaning option. The directional water spray and sometimes fully customisable stream ensures a satisfactory clean, albeit without the flexibility of a handheld bidet.

    This type of bidet is particularly beneficial for individuals who may have mobility issues as it requires less manual operation compared to a handheld bidet.

    Installation

    The installation process for a toilet seat mounted bidet is more complex compared to its handheld or attachment counterparts. These bidets replace your existing toilet seat and are usually attached to the toilet's water supply, ensuring a continuous supply of fresh water.

    It's vital that the system has a backflow prevention feature to avoid cross-contamination in case of low pressure, which might require professional installation. The water used by the bidet seat comes from the water line used to fill the toilet tank, not from the toilet bowl, ensuring a clean and sanitary experience​.

    Cost Effectiveness

    The financial aspect of investing in a toilet seat mounted bidet diverges from the conventional narrative of cost savings. Unlike the economical bidet sprays, the initial expenditure for a toilet seat mounted bidet is significantly higher, often running into several hundred dollars based on the model and brand. The narrative here shifts from mere cost savings to an enriched quality of life.

    The allure of a toilet seat mounted bidet lies in its plethora of advanced features that transcend the basic functionality of a bidet spray. From heated seats and adjustable water temperature to customizable water pressure and even air dryers, the gamut of comfort and convenience-oriented features contributes to a superior restroom experience.

    While these bidets do usher in savings on toilet paper expenditure over time, the core value proposition is the enhancement in personal hygiene and the luxurious comfort they offer, making them a desirable, albeit pricier, upgrade for your bathroom sanctuary.

    Maintenance

    Maintenance is relatively straightforward but crucial for the longevity and effectiveness of the bidet. Regular cleaning with non-abrasive cleaners is essential to keep the bidet free from grime and bacteria.

    Despite the self-cleaning feature of the nozzle, periodic manual cleaning with cleaning solutions is necessary to ensure optimum hygiene as the self-cleaning is done with water only.

    In a nutshell, toilet seat mounted bidets are an epitome of modern, hygienic, and convenient bathroom fixtures that not only enhance personal cleanliness but also bring a touch of elegance to your bathroom ambiance.

    Smart Toilet Bidet System: The Future?

    smart bidet system

    In a world where smart technology reigns supreme, the bathroom is no exception. Enter the Smart Toilet Bidet System or so called Luxury Electric Bidet, a contemporary marvel that takes your bathroom experience to a futuristic level.

    This sophisticated system is not merely a toilet; it's an epitome of modern-day luxury and convenience - simply the best bidet. Here's a closer look at this modern marvel:

    Features

    Smart Toilet Electric Bidet Systems are not just regular toilets. They come with a bunch of cool features that make using the bathroom more comfortable and clean. With an easy-to-use remote, you can control how the bidet works. There's an eco mode to save energy when you're not using the toilet, and customizable settings to get the water stream just right for cleaning. The heat settings make sure the seat and water are warm, which is really nice.

    The bidet has retractable nozzles that spray warm water to clean your bottom or private parts. Some models even have massaging features for a better clean. It's like having a mini spa right in your bathroom with so many features to make using the toilet a better experience. And the companies making these fancy bidets keep adding new features to make your bathroom visits even better.

    User Friendliness

    These high-tech electric toilets are designed with user-friendliness in mind. The controls are often intuitive, with remote controls or touch-panel operations that are easy to navigate. With the touch of a button, you can customize your bathroom visit to your liking.

    Some models even come with a mobile app, enabling you to control and customize the settings from your smartphone. With these top of the line luxury bidets, toilet paper use can be completely eliminated.

    Electricity Consumption

    While the enhanced features are enticing, they do require a significant amount of electricity to function. The heated seat, warm water, air drying, and other features contribute to higher energy consumption compared to traditional toilets or simpler bidet setups. It's a trade-off between luxury and energy efficiency.

    Installation

    The installation of a Smart Toilet Bidet System is a more complex task, often requiring professional installation due to the electrical and plumbing modifications needed. It's not a plug-and-play setup and may require some bathroom remodelling to accommodate the system.

    Versatility

    Smart Toilet Bidet Systems are versatile in terms of functionality but are fixed installations. They provide a comprehensive range of features for a comfortable and hygienic bathroom experience but lack the portability of hand-held bidet sprayers.

    Affordability

    These systems are on the higher end of the price spectrum when it comes to bidet solutions. The advanced features and sophisticated technology come at a premium cost. However, for those willing to invest, the benefits and comfort provided by a Smart Toilet Bidet System are unparalleled.

    Comfort

    The comfort provided by a Smart Toilet Bidet System is top-notch. The heated seat, warm water, and air drying features ensure a comfortable experience, especially in colder climates. The adjustable water pressure and temperature settings allow for a personalized bathroom experience. It is likely you will experience one of the best rear washes you ever have.

    Aesthetics

    Smart Toilet Bidet Systems are sleek and modern, often with a minimalist design that can complement contemporary bathroom decors. Their high-tech appearance can add a touch of modernity and luxury to your bathroom.

    Maintenance

    Maintenance of a Smart Toilet Bidet System involves regular cleaning and occasional professional servicing to ensure the electronic components are functioning correctly. The self-cleaning nozzle feature is a boon, but manual cleaning is still necessary to ensure optimal hygiene.

    Comparison of Different Bidets

    Navigating through the sea of bidet choices can initially seem daunting. Each type of bidet brings along its unique set of features, user-friendliness, installation requirements, and aesthetic appeal.

    To help distill down the essentials and provide a clear vista of what each bidet type entails, we've crafted a comparison table.

    This table juxtaposes the four common types of bidets—Hand-held Bidet, Toilet Seat Attachment Bidet, Toilet Seat Mounted Bidet, and Smart Toilet Bidet System—across a spectrum of functionalities and attributes. Whether you're veering towards the eco-friendliness of a hand-held bidet or the luxury of a smart toilet bidet system, this table will serve as a roadmap, guiding you towards making an informed decision that aligns with your needs and preferences.

    The insights provided alongside further elucidate the stark contrasts and similarities among these bidet types, aiding in honing down on the bidet that resonates with your lifestyle and bathroom ethos.

    Features

    Hand-held Bidet

    Toilet Seat Attachment Bidet

    Toilet Seat Mounted Bidet

    Smart Toilet Bidet System

    Adjustable Water Pressure

    Yes

    Yes

    Yes

    Yes

    Adjustable Water Temperature

    No

    Sometimes

    Yes

    Yes

    Air Dry

    No

    No

    Sometimes

    Yes

    Heated Seat

    No

    No

    Sometimes

    Yes

    Self-Cleaning Nozzle

    No

    Sometimes

    Yes

    Yes

    Deodorizer

    No

    No

    Sometimes

    Yes

    Remote Control

    No

    No

    Sometimes

    Yes

    User Friendliness

    Medium

    Medium

    High

    High

    Electricity Consumption

    None

    Low

    Medium

    High

    Installation Complexity

    Low

    Low

    Medium

    High

    Versatility

    High

    Medium

    Low

    Low

    Affordability

    High

    High

    Medium

    Low

    Comfort

    Low

    Medium

    High

    High

    Aesthetics

    Low

    Medium

    High

    High

    Insights

    • Electricity Consumption: Hand-held bidets consume no electricity making them the most eco-friendly, while Smart Toilet Bidet Systems consume the most due to their numerous electric features.

    • Installation Complexity: Hand-held and Toilet Seat Attachment Bidets are relatively easy to install, unlike Smart Toilet Bidet Systems which require professional installation.

    • Versatility: Hand-held bidets are highly versatile and can be used for various cleaning tasks, unlike other bidet types that are fixed installations.

    • Affordability: Hand-held and Toilet Seat Attachment Bidets are the most affordable options, making them accessible for a wider range of users.

    • Comfort: Toilet Seat Mounted and Smart Toilet Bidet Systems provide the highest level of comfort due to features like heated seats and adjustable water temperature.

    • Aesthetics: Smart Toilet Bidet Systems and Toilet Seat Mounted Bidets have a sleek, modern appearance that can complement contemporary bathroom decors.

    The Verdict: Handheld Bidet, A Wise Choice for the Everyday Household

    In the quest for an enhanced bathroom adventure, the array of bidet options available can indeed boggle the mind. However, for the average household seeking a blend of functionality, cost-effectiveness, and ease of use, the handheld bidet emerges as a clear winner.

    Here's our breakdown on why the handheld bidet - the standard bidet could be the quintessential choice for most households:

    Cost-Effectiveness:

    The handheld bidet is undeniably the most budget-friendly option amongst its counterparts. Its upfront cost is significantly lower, making it a minimal-risk investment for those unfamiliar with bidet use. Moreover, the savings on toilet paper expenditure over time are a substantial benefit, with the handheld bidet offering the best bang for your buck.

    Ease of Installation:

    Setting up a handheld bidet is a straightforward DIY task that doesn’t necessitate any special tools or professional assistance, unlike the more complex installation required for toilet seat mounted and smart toilet bidet systems.

    This ease of installation is particularly beneficial for renters as the handheld bidet does not require any substantial modifications to the existing toilet setup.

    Versatility:

    The flexible hose of the handheld bidet is a game-changer, allowing for a variety of uses besides personal hygiene. Whether it's cleaning pets, rinsing off diapers, or even tackling stubborn toilet bowl stains, the handheld bidet is up to the task. This multifaceted functionality is something that's uniquely inherent to the handheld bidet design.

    Eco-Friendliness:

    In a world progressively leaning towards green living, the handheld bidet is a step in the right direction. Its water usage is conservative compared to the potential wastage of paper, aligning with eco-conscious living principles.

    User Control:

    The handheld bidet affords users a level of control that automated bidets can't match. Users can adjust the pressure and direction of the spray as per personal comfort, making the cleaning process more efficient and personalized.

    Minimalist Aesthetic:

    For those with a penchant for minimalist design, the handheld bidet seamlessly blends in with modern bathroom aesthetics without demanding the space that toilet seat mounted or smart toilet bidet systems might require.

    Maintenance Simplicity:

    Maintenance of a handheld bidet is straightforward. A regular cleaning routine keeps it hygienic and functioning optimally. Moreover, should any issue arise, resolving it is typically more straightforward and less costly compared to addressing problems in more complex bidet systems.

    The modest handheld bidet, with its blend of simplicity, functionality, and cost-effectiveness, stands out as a prudent choice for the modern household. While it may lack the luxury features of high-end bidet systems, it fulfils the core purpose of a bidet, promoting enhanced hygiene and convenience in the restroom.

    Thus, for the average household, the handheld bidet is a commendable choice that aligns with both budgetary and functional considerations, making the transition from traditional to modern bathroom hygiene a breeze.

    Conclusion

    The realm of bidets offers various options to cater to your cleanliness and comfort. Whether you choose the simple hand-held, the convenient attachment, the comfy seat-mounted, or the luxurious smart system, a bidet is a valuable addition to your bathroom.

    Your choice will depend on your personal circumstances, preferences, and budget. Whatever you choose, a refreshing and hygienic bathroom experience awaits you!

    Join the Discussion

    0 comments
    Products mentioned in Blog

    Bumwash Lite Bidet Spray Set

    Bumwash Pro Dual Mode Bidet Spray Set

    Bumwash Pro Bidet Spray Set - Black

    Bumwash Pro Bidet Spray Set - Chrome

    Bumwash Pro Bidet Spray Set - Gold

    Keep on reading
    All Blogs

    Join the Bumwash Community

    Get the latest in Bumwash product updates, insights on bum health and news on special deals.